How The J. M. Smucker Company stacks up

SJM · against 149 other Consumer Defensive companies listed in US-listed

Valuation

40/ 100

Below the middle of the pack.

Ranked #82 of 150 · scores higher than 45% of peers

Bars: peers in each 10-point band of the valuation score

21 peers with a valuation score of 40–49, including SJM · Click a bar to see the companies

Why valuation scores 40?

Weighted metrics compared with all Consumer Defensive companies.

A mix: stronger free cash flow yield and EBITDA yield, but weaker earnings yield than most Consumer Defensive peers.

lower earnings for the price paid: weaker than 75% of peers. Earnings yield: 1.7% vs peer median 4.5%
more operating profit (EBITDA) for the company's total value: stronger than 63% of peers. EBITDA yield: 6.8% vs peer median 8.7%
more free cash flow for the price paid: stronger than 76% of peers. Free cash flow yield: 11.6% vs peer median 6.2%

Metric by metric

Position: dot = SJM, ranked from the worst peer (left) to the best (right); tick = middle, shaded = middle half of peers.

Metric	SJM	Peer median	Better than	Weight
Earnings yieldHigher is better · 146 reported	1.7%	3.7%	30%	30%
EBITDA yieldHigher is better · 151 reported	10.9%	9.0%	65%	50%
Free cash flow yieldHigher is better · 132 reported	11.6%	5.8%	82%	20%
Book yieldHigher is better · 145 reported	42.1%	39.9%	53%	Context only

Ranking by valuation score

Top 5 and the companies ranked around SJM

Rank	Company	Market cap	Valuation	Overall
1	Afya LimitedAFYA · US-listed	933M USD	97	84
2	Nature's Sunshine Products, Inc.NATR · US-listed	212M USD	93	72
2	Phoenix Education Partners, Inc.PXED · US-listed	843M USD	93	88
4	Smithfield Foods, Inc.SFD · US-listed	7.2B USD	92	72
5	BellRing Brands, Inc.BRBR · US-listed	1.1B USD	91	67
⋯
76	Newell Brands Inc.NWL · US-listed	2.4B USD	42	25
80	Kenvue Inc.KVUE · US-listed	37.1B USD	41	48
80	Performance Food Group CompanyPFGC · US-listed	15.2B USD	41	36
82	BJ's Wholesale Club Holdings, Inc.BJ · US-listed	13.8B USD	40	59
82	The J. M. Smucker CompanySJM · US-listed	13.7B USD	40	46
84	The Clorox CompanyCLX · US-listed	11.3B USD	39	35
84	Coca-Cola Consolidated, Inc.COKE · US-listed	13.7B USD	39	51
84	KinderCare Learning Companies, Inc.KLC · US-listed	244M USD	39	21
84	Grand Canyon Education, Inc.LOPE · US-listed	3.9B USD	39	64

Scores are sector-relative percentiles from the latest snapshot, always calculated against the whole sector: narrowing the comparison group changes who you compare with, not the scores. Missing metrics are left out and the remaining weights rescaled. How we score

Bringing the fundamentals into focus…